📖 You’re Overthinking This
✍️ Diana Urban
🎙️ Kelli Tager
🎁 NetGalley & RB Media
📅 Release: 11/19/26
🏁 Finished: 11/10/26
⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Well, this story definitely went in a direction I wasn’t expecting, but I was HERE for it! And honestly, without giving anything away, the twist was surprisingly plausible. Logical, even. Which somehow made everything even better!

Hailey is leaving town for a fresh start, but the roads have other plans. Instead, she finds herself stranded at a cabin with Cameron, a hot Australian stranger. Sounds like the beginning of a romance, right? Well… not exactly.

I absolutely loved that almost immediately after arriving, Hailey discovers a BODY IN THE FREEZER. Naturally, her mind starts racing through every possible scenario, trying to figure out what the heck she’s gotten herself into. And honestly? SAME, GIRL. SAME. I’d be questioning every little thing!

From there, we get a little steam, a LOT of chaos, some morally gray undertones, and eventually… answers! I really enjoyed how the story unfolded, especially because it managed to surprise me while still making sense. Sometimes twists feel like they’re thrown in just for shock value, but this one actually worked for me.

I listened to the audiobook narrated by Kelli Tager, and overall, I really enjoyed her performance! I wasn’t a huge fan of her Australian male accent for Cameron, which didn’t quite work for me. That said, I thought she did a great job with the rest of the narration, and I enjoyed listening as Hailey’s situation became increasingly chaotic!

Overall, this was a fun, twisty, and entertaining read that kept me guessing. If you enjoy thrillers with unexpected turns, questionable situations, and a little morally gray behavior thrown into the mix, definitely give this one a try!